Homeowners InsuranceSanta Barbara Insurance

How to Get Off the California FAIR Plan in Santa Barbara County

By November 18, 2026No Comments

How to Get Off the California FAIR Plan in Santa Barbara County

By Dan Baxter, Baxter Insurance

Over the last few years, a lot of good, careful homeowners in Santa Barbara County opened their mail to find a non-renewal letter. It wasn’t anything they did. Large carriers pulled back from wildfire areas across California, and many families ended up on the California FAIR Plan as a last resort.

The FAIR Plan has kept a lot of people insured, and we’re glad it exists. But it was never meant to be a long-term home. Here’s what you should know, and what we do to help clients move back to a full homeowners policy.

What the FAIR Plan Covers, and What It Doesn’t

The FAIR Plan is a basic fire policy. It covers fire, lightning, smoke and a few other perils, with dwelling limits up to $3 million. It does not include the things most people expect from home insurance:

  • Theft of your belongings

  • Water damage from a burst pipe or leaking water heater

  • Personal liability if someone is hurt on your property

  • Many other coverages included in a standard homeowners policy

Step 1: Fill the Gaps With a DIC Policy

If the FAIR Plan is your only option right now, don’t leave those gaps open. A Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy wraps around the FAIR Plan and adds back theft, water damage, liability and more. Together, the two policies work much like a full homeowners policy. We set them up together so the coverages line up with no gaps.

Step 2: Harden Your Home

Carriers look closely at wildfire mitigation. A Class A roof, ember-resistant vents, enclosed eaves, multi-pane windows and a clear five-foot zone around your home all help. Under California’s Safer from Wildfires program, insurers, including the FAIR Plan, must offer discounts for these steps. Keep photos and receipts for any work you do. They help us make your case to underwriters.

Step 3: Re-Shop Every Renewal

The market changes. Carriers that weren’t writing new business last year may be open this year, especially for homes with good mitigation. As an independent agency, we shop admitted carriers like Chubb and Farmers, along with surplus lines markets, and we re-check FAIR Plan homes at every renewal.

Step 4: Don’t Let Your Limits Slip

Whatever policy you’re on, make sure your dwelling limit reflects what it would cost to rebuild today. Construction costs on the South Coast have climbed fast, and being underinsured after a total loss is the most expensive mistake a homeowner can make.

We Insure Every Neighborhood

From Carpinteria and Montecito to Santa Barbara, Hope Ranch and Goleta, we help homeowners in every part of the county. If you’ve been non-renewed or you’re on the FAIR Plan today, call us. We’ll review your situation and show you every option available.

Talk to a Local Agent

Every home and every business is different, and so is every policy. If you have questions, call our office at (805) 963-4048 or request a free quote online. Our licensed team has served Santa Barbara County since 1989, and we’re happy to review your coverage at no cost.

This article is general information only. It is not an insurance policy and does not change any coverage. Your policy’s actual terms, conditions and exclusions determine what is covered.